Classy Cookies by NW

About Classy Cookies

Meet the baker

What began as a mom who loves to make cookies has grown into a small custom bakery known for beautifully decorated sugar cookies.

Delicate floral sugar cookies piped with royal icing blossoms

Classy Cookies started the way the best things often do, at home and out of love. What began as a mom who loves to make cookies has grown into a small custom bakery known for beautifully decorated sugar cookies. Decorating alongside her three sons and their friends turned into a favorite kind of bonding time, and that same care goes into every cookie that leaves the kitchen.

Each order is decorated by hand, one cookie at a time, and designed around your celebration. No two orders are quite the same, and that is exactly the point.

Classy Cookies by NW

  • Home-based, made to order
  • Decorated entirely by hand
  • Serving the greater Milwaukee area

Ingredients & allergens

Our original sugar cookies are made with a nut-free recipe and are tree-nut and peanut free. They do contain wheat and eggs. Gluten-friendly flavors are available on request.

Please note: cookies are baked in an open-concept home kitchen where nuts may occasionally be present and cross-contamination is possible. Our gluten-friendly options are not recommended for severe gluten allergies. If you have a serious allergy, please tell us when you order.

Sugar cookies

Enriched bleached flour (wheat flour, niacin, iron, thiamin mononitrate, riboflavin, folic acid), butter (cream [milk], salt), pure cane sugar, eggs, pure vanilla extract, cookie nip flavoring, baking powder, coarse kosher salt.

Royal icing

Pure cane powdered sugar, water, light corn syrup, meringue powder, vanilla extract, cream of tartar.

Close-up of Classy Cookies ingredients and decorated sugar cookies

Good to know

Frequently asked questions

Let us bake something special

Ready to order, or have a question?

The best way to start an order is to call or text with your date, occasion and any ideas you have in mind. We would love to hear from you.

Best way to order

Call or text us

Share your date, occasion and any inspiration photos. We will help design cookies that fit your celebration.

(414) 491-9929

Call to order Text to order

Prefer email? An email address is coming soon. For now, a quick call or text is the fastest way to reach us.

Serving Hales Corners and the greater Milwaukee area. Local delivery available up to 30 miles.