Custom decorated cookies • Hales Corners, WI
Cookies almost too pretty to eat.
Hand-decorated royal icing sugar cookies, made to order for your weddings, showers, birthdays and every moment worth celebrating.
Ordering is by call or text at (414) 491-9929.
Edible art for your celebration
Cookies made just for your day
Classy Cookies makes custom sugar cookies decorated one at a time with royal icing. Every order is designed around your event, your colors and your theme, so the cookies feel like they were made just for the day. Baked fresh to order in Hales Corners, and made with a nut-free recipe.
Made to order
Every cookie is custom decorated by hand for your event.
Nut-free recipe
Our original sugar cookie is tree-nut and peanut free.
Local to Milwaukee
Pickup in Hales Corners, with delivery available nearby.
Occasions we bake for
If it is worth celebrating, it is worth a custom cookie.
From the first shower to the big day and every birthday in between, we design cookies to match the moment.
Weddings & engagements
Elegant cookies to match your palette, from the proposal to the reception.
Bridal & baby showers
Sweet, on-theme favors your guests will want to photograph.
Birthdays & Sweet 16
Bright, personalized designs for the guest of honor.
First Communion
Delicate, meaningful cookies for a special milestone.
Anniversaries & retirement
Custom cookies to mark the moments that matter.
Teacher & staff appreciation
A thoughtful, personal way to say thank you.
Holidays & seasonal
Assorted seasonal designs, baker's choice, all year round.
Business & logo cookies
Your brand or logo printed edible and delivered ready to impress.
Do not see your occasion? If you can dream it, we can likely decorate it. Just ask.
How ordering works
Simple, personal and made to fit your event.
Reach out
Call or text (414) 491-9929 with your date, occasion and any ideas or inspiration photos.
Design together
We talk through your theme, colors and design so your cookies fit the celebration.
Confirm the details
We finalize quantity, design and pickup or delivery. Please allow the lead times noted on each item.
Pick up or delivered
Pick up free in Hales Corners, or add local delivery. Your cookies arrive ready to celebrate.
Custom orders book up, especially around holidays and weekends. The earlier you reach out, the better we can accommodate your date.
A little sweetness to browse
A look at cookies made for real celebrations.
Every set is decorated by hand and designed around a specific event. Browse for inspiration, then reach out to create your own.
Good to know
Questions, answered.
A few of the most common ones. Have another? Call or text and we are happy to help.
See all FAQsLet us bake something special
Ready to order, or have a question? The best way to start is a quick call or text with your date, occasion and any ideas you have in mind.